Blog

Questions to ask before hiring a podcast editing agency

Matt MilneBy 5 min read

Ask a podcast editing agency ten things before hiring: who edits your show, who covers when they are away, what counts as a revision and whether rounds are capped, where notes go, who owns the finished and project files in writing, what happens to raw footage, what the billing period is, what a skipped week costs, how the schedule holds in a busy week, and whether you can pay for one episode first. Vague answers on ownership and revisions are the two to walk away from.

On this page
  1. Who is going to edit your show?
  2. How do revisions work in practice?
  3. What do you own when the work is done?
  4. How does the billing run, and what about a busy week?
  5. What do good and bad answers sound like?
  6. Our answers, so you can hold us to them

Every agency call covers the same ground: the showreel, the process slide, the price. None of it tells you what month four is like. These ten questions do. Put them in this order, on the call or in an email beforehand, and write the answers down. Each one has a line on why it is there. Finding candidates is a separate job, covered in how to hire a podcast editor in the UK.

Who is going to edit your show?

  1. "Who edits my episodes, by name?" The person on the sales call is often not the person in the timeline. Ask who opens your files. An editor who knows your host's habits by episode five is most of what you are paying for.
  2. "Who covers when that person is away, and how do they pick the show up?" Cover is the main reason to choose an agency over a single freelancer. If the answer is a shrug, you are paying agency rates for a freelancer's risk.
  3. "Do I talk to the editor, or to an account manager?" Neither is wrong. But a note that passes through two people arrives slower and vaguer than one left on the exact second of the cut.

For comparison, at Joycast the same editors work on your show every episode, and your notes go straight to the people cutting.

How do revisions work in practice?

  1. "What counts as a revision, and is there a cap on rounds?" Get the policy before you need it. A cap sounds reasonable until the episode that needs one more pass.

    Here is why we ask it this way. On one leadership show in our archive, four episodes in a row each have three exported versions: a first cut, then two rounds of changes. The running time barely moved between them (one stayed at about 46 minutes across all three). A later episode on the same show went to a fourth version, and so did episode twelve of a climate show we cut. That is what normal looks like: small changes, a couple of rounds, and now and then an episode that needs more. Under a "two rounds included" policy, those fourth versions are the ones that get invoiced. Ours are not; revisions run until you are happy, with no round limits.

  2. "Where do I leave notes, and who reads them?" Timestamped comments on the video beat a long email. Ask to see what a real round of notes looks like.

What do you own when the work is done?

  1. "Who owns the finished files and the project files, and where is that written down?" Do not assume paying for the edit makes it yours. The UK's Intellectual Property Office says that when you commission work, the first legal owner of the copyright is whoever created it, "unless you otherwise agree it in writing" (ownership of copyright works). So ask for the line in the terms, not a reassurance on the call.
  2. "What happens to my raw footage if I leave?" You want it handed back, or deleted on request, without a fee. Project files matter as well: without them, the next editor rebuilds your titles and captions from nothing.

How does the billing run, and what about a busy week?

  1. "What is the billing period, is there a minimum term, and is VAT on top?" A monthly retainer, a per-episode price and a day rate can describe the same work at very different totals. Ask for a per-episode figure so you can compare.
  2. "What do I pay if I skip a week or pause between seasons?" A retainer that keeps charging through a quiet month is paying for the agency's calendar, not your show.
  3. "When three clients send files in the same week, what happens to mine?" A good answer describes a schedule: when files are checked, when the first cut comes back, and who tells you if something is wrong with the recording. Promises of speed are not a schedule. We go through the stages in how long podcast editing should take.

One more, if the first ten go well: "Can I pay for a single episode before agreeing to a run?" One real episode tells you more than any of the answers above.

What do good and bad answers sound like?

Question Worth a second call Walk away
Who edits? A named editor, and a named cover "Our team"
Revisions A written policy with no round fees "Two rounds, then we quote"
Ownership A clause giving you every file "We keep the project files"
Billing A per-episode price and no minimum term A 12-month contract
Busy week A weekly schedule they can describe "We always deliver"

Our answers, so you can hold us to them

It would be odd to publish the list and not answer it. A full episode edit is £280, with 10% off the whole package at three or more episodes. Billing is per four-week cycle, with no minimum term and no VAT. We work in weekly cycles. Revisions run until you are happy. Every finished file and project file is yours. To see how other agencies' answers compare on price, read what podcast editing costs in the UK.

The rest is on the pricing page. If you are an agency looking for an editing partner for a client's show, the same questions apply to us, and the answers are on the agencies page.

If you'd rather hand the edit over, here's what a full episode edit includes and what it costs.

Sources

  1. Intellectual Property Office: ownership of copyright works
  2. Joycast: pricing

Send us your next recording.

Price your show